Beissel and Baumann

From Chronicon Ephratense (1786): "There arose about that time [1721] a people in the neighborhood of Oley in Berks County, who called themselves the Newborn, and had one Matthias Baumann as their founder. Their profession was that they could not sin anymore. In a pamphlet of 35 pages, 8vo, printed in Germany, and entitled "A Call to the Unregenerate World," it sounds wonderful to hear Baumann say, on page 13: 'Men say that Christ hath taken away sin; it is true in my case, and of those who are in the same condition in which Adam was before the fall, as I am,'--where he places himself by the side of Adam before his fall. And on page 16 he makes a still bolder leap when he says: 'As Adam was before the fall, so have I become, and even firmer.' But what provoked people most was what he says on page 12: 'With the body one cannot sin before God but only before men and other creatures, and these the Judge can settle,' from which they drew dangerous conclusions. They boasted that they had only been sent by God to confound men, a work which they also diligently carried on during ten years, so that their disputations at market times in Philadelphia were often heard with astonishment, where also Baumann once offered, in order to prove that his doctrine was from God, to walk across the Delaware river.

In their journeys through Conestoga, where they here and there found acceptance, they finally also came to the Superintendent, [Conrad Beissel] where Baumann commenced about the new birth. The Superintendent gave him little satisfaction, telling him to smell of his own filth, and then consider whether this belonged to the new birth; whereupon they called him a crafty spirit full of subtility, and departed. It was ob served that from this time on they lost all power to spread their seductions any further, which finally died out with their originators. The Baumann spoken of died about the year 1727. He is said otherwise to have been an upright man, and not to have loved the wrold inordinately; but Kuehlenwein, Jotter, and other followers of his were insatiable in their love of the world." (16-18. Translated by Max Hark, 1889)

"For many centuries the importance of the body, of matter, has been devalued. Importance has always been given to the human "soul" or, in another generalizing view, a person's place in the socio-political structure and the economy. But history shows that the body has always been the main locus of the oppression and appropriation of women, as it has also been with other oppressed groups (for example indigenous and black peoples): this has been done through rape, aggression, denial, abuse, manipulation, idealization. For this very reason, the body cannot be considered as a mere side-issue in any reading of the Bible which asks questions about gender relations. Life and death manifest themselves through the body. Restoring the physical body to its rightful place is a fundamental part of our affirmation of a real and sensual life." [restoration of the body, resurrection of the body] Nancy Cardoso Pereira. The body as a hermeneuticalcategory

Religious arguments as rhetoric are as taken with the sensational as broadcast news. The most quoted statement of Baumann subsequently is that "those who are in the same condition in which Adam was before the fall, as I am." What he could mean other than drama is anybody's guess since what Adam was before the fall is a tad speculative. Try Adam on Venus in Perelandra.


See Sachse, The German Sectarians of Pennsylvania 1708-1742 on the Newborn, p 73f.

John Joseph Stoudt. The First American Oecumenical Movement, 1940. m. Baumann. in Church History, Dec 1940
http://www.jstor.org/pss/3160914